DID BHAGAT SINGH SUCCEED?

[*BabeS iN dE 'WooD*]

Well baccheyon yesterday my cousinzz frm uk were discussing dis wid me...(( as dey really duno much abt dee thingz)) thay asked me dis question ki y didnt Bhagat singh succeed?? they say well he was not d one who kicked dem out...becoz dose people used 2 call members of HSRA- terrorists they werent popular !!! aae tan fer discussion War ch badal gi..lolzz

but wat i think By Success do u mean Bhagat Singh Lived or died !!! well Death never made a difference foe him !! it was his visions tht he wanted to live !!! and I have his vision @@@ and lots of them like me too (( baute ne Lc te)) !!! so his vision livez and he livez !!! he alwayz wanted to die for the nation !! nd that death was no match fo his intelligence nd courage !! by abusing others ur nor Showin patriotism to ur country Mate!!

so u guyzz tell me..if i was rite or wrong??

[Aashi_Sekhon]

Originally Posted by *BabeS iN dE 'WooD* Well baccheyon yesterday my cousinzz frm uk were discussing dis wid me...(( as dey really duno much abt dee thingz)) thay asked me dis question ki y didnt Bhagat singh succeed?? they say well he was not d one who kicked dem out...becoz dose people used 2 call members of HSRA- terrorists they werent popular !!! aae tan fer discussion War ch badal gi..lolzz but wat i think By Success do u mean Bhagat Singh Lived or died !!! well Death never made a difference foe him !! it was his visions tht he wanted to live !!! and I have his vision @@@ and lots of them like me too (( baute ne Lc te)) !!! so his vision livez and he livez !!! he alwayz wanted to die for the nation !! nd that death was no match fo his intelligence nd courage !! by abusing others ur nor Showin patriotism to ur country Mate!! so u guyzz tell me..if i was rite or wrong??

Bhagat Singh's last petition
"We are prisoners of war shoot us instead of hanging..... The war will not stop with our killing"

well said babes.........ur absolutely rite and INfact I think everyone will agree to u......Bhagat Singh is still somewhere in all of us.....I can relate my thoughts completely to his thoughts and love for the country... nale Bhagat Singh warge lnsaan kade nei marde but ikk lesson deke jande ne har ikk desh waasi nu...

[Jonty509]

Well Done Ishu.....u started a good topic to discuss.....Well succeed hon to ki matlab aa eh taan menu samaj nahi lagya....but haan je nation di gall aondi aa taan they def. got success....uhna di shahidi ton baad desh ch ik nawa inqalab jaagya te kine hi bhagat singh paida hoye...jina ne desh layee janna waria....te uh sade layee ik misal ban gaye.....par jadon society di gall aondi hai...taan menu bada dukh hunda soch ke....ki eda wadda soorma society baare jo khyal rakhda c ...us ch uh succeed nahi hoya.....uh sochde c...ki india di azadi sirf angrezan da chale jaana nahi...balki Jaat paat ...te dharam de bhed bhav ton azad hona hi asli azadi hai.....so uh ik edan de india da khwab dekhde c..jis vich communalism naam di koi cheez naa hove...par afsos asin aje v dharam te jaat paat de naam te bhed bhav karde aa.....jadon v asin kise nu niwi jaat da samjde aa...taan menu sharam aondi hai....ki asin us mahan shaheed diya thoughts nu bhula dita hai....tusi sare apne dil te hath rakh ke soch ke dekho ki tusin bhed bhav nahi karde jaat paat de naam te....je nahi taan tusin sache desh bhagat ho.....sirf nation layee jaan deni hi deshbhagti nahi...us nation nu ik mahan nation banaona jithe sare iko jahe hon v desh bhagti hai.......

sorry friends jadon bhagat singh ji di gall aondi aa taan main zara jyada senti ho jana...but uh ik soorma c....jisne desh di azadi te samaj di azadi da supna dekhya c.....pahle supne ch uh jaroor succeed hoya par afsos dooje supne ch nahi....te us dooje supne nu saakar sirf asin kar sakde haan......

Thanks Ayisha ena vadhia topic start karan layee........

[Natthu]

today is bhagat singhs birthday so wishes to all punjabis and namashkar hai punjab de dharti nu jis ne bhagat singh varge shaheed nu janam dita. PROUD TO BE PUNJABI.

[munda_wakhre_type_da]

well bhagat singh never ever fought to get in power..

una ne prime minister yaaa president yaa fer koi hor neta banan karke ni azadi di ladai ladi c.. he fought to get freedom he fought for da cause..

j oh v gandhi ya nehru waaang scheman ji paake ya politics ch peke lad de.. shayad ooo v fansi naa chad de and azadi to baad president yaa prime minister banke hi rehnde..and thode cousins babes ji ajj eh swaaal na puchde k oo succeed kun ni kar sake..

bt trust me una di qurbani hi baaaki neta logaan di success di key bani c.. and on top of dat he wasnt given dat much appreciation and respect which he deserved..
infact gandhi opposed him..wtever dnt wanna discuss us level te...

bt appreciation te regard taaa ohi matter karda jo ik aaam insaaaan dinda.. and i know jo respect bhagat singh layi lokan de dilan ch hai oh hor kise politicain layi ni ho sakdi..

[Sukhpal.Tiwana]

well ur very right, Bhagat Singh Had this thought that if he gave his life for the freedom than this would work like feul in fire, and he was right , He became a hero in general people of india and all communities came together against british.
This was his success, But today our country is forgetting them all, all of those who really died for us!!!!

[Dhana_Jatt]

Originally Posted by natthu today is bhagat singhs birthday so wishes to all punjabis and namashkar hai punjab de dharti nu jis ne bhagat singh varge shaheed nu janam dita. PROUD TO BE PUNJABI.

bai ji bhagat singh da b'day 28 sept nu hai.... ajj nahi....fer v thank you tusi yaad krata

[H0nest_L0ver]

Originally Posted by dhana_jatt bai ji bhagat singh da b'day 28 sept nu hai.... ajj nahi....fer v thank you tusi yaad krata

BORN: Sept. 27, 1907, Punjab, India

1930: Threw bombs in Central Assembly Hall, protesting on imposing severe measures like the Trades Disputes Bill by the Britishers.

1930: Went on hunger strike to protest the inhuman treatment of fellow-political prisoners by jail authorities.

1930: Sukh Dev and Raj Guru, he was awarded the death sentence. Cremated on the bank of the Sutlej in Ferozepur.

Died: Hanged in the early hours of March 23, 1931.

Cremated at: Ferozepur, Punjab.

Bhagat Singh was born on September 27, 1907, in Khatkar Kalan, Punjab, in British India. His grandfather Arjan Singh, father Kishan Singh and uncle Ajit Singh, were all active in the freedom struggle.

While studying at the local D.A.V. School in Lahore, in 1916, young Bhagat Singh came into contact with some well-known political leaders like Lala Lajpat Rai and Ras Bihari Bose.

In response to Mahatma Gandhi's call for non-cooperation against British rule in 1921, Bhagat Singh left his school and joined the National College newly opened at Lahore. At this college, which was a centre of revolutionary activities, he came into contact with revolutionaries such as Bhagwati Charan, Sukhdev and others. He became a member of the Hindustan Republican Association formed by the revolutionaries of Uttar Pradesh and was initiated into their firebrand activities.

The revolutionaries were branded as terrorists by the British government. They believed that given the unjust and oppressive nature of British rule, it was legitimate on their part to use violence as a weapon to overthrow the foreigners. So, they used bombs and guns against Britishers and robbed establishments belonging to the British or their sympathisers.

Their ideas differed from the Gandhian idea of a freedom movement based on non-violence or ahimsa. Gandhi's ideas went on to become more prominent as the Indian freedom movement progressed.

But it is not merely as a bold militant-type figure that Bhagat Singh is remembered today. He was also a thinker who was steeped in the best traditions of socialistic thought, the theory that advocated collective or state ownership of the means of production - land, labour and capital. This is borne out in the numerous letters, pamphlets and articles that he wrote in the course of a short but turbulent life.

In a letter to an Indian publication, The Tribune of December 24, 1929, Bhagat Singh explained beautifully the meaning he and fellow socialists tried to convey by the phrase, Long Live Revolution. He wrote that by revolution, they did not so much mean violence, as "the spirit, the longing for a change for the better." Since people generally get accustomed to the established order of things and begin to tremble at the very idea of a change, they needed to be roused from their lethargy and the revolutionary spirit had to be instilled in them.

A brutal attack by the police on veteran freedom fighter Lala Lajpat Rai at an anti-British procession caused his death on November 17 1928, in Lahore.

Bhagat Singh determined to avenge Lajpat Rai's death by shooting the British official responsible for the killing, Deputy Inspector General Scott. He shot down Assistant Superintendent Saunders instead, mistaking him for Scott.

Then he made a dramatic escape from Lahore to Calcutta and from there to Agra, where he established a bomb factory.

The British government responded to the act by imposing severe measures like the Trades Disputes Bill. It was to protest against the passing of the Bill that he threw bombs in the Central Assembly Hall while the Assembly was in session. The bombs did not hurt anyone, but the noise they made was loud enough to wake up an enslaved nation from a long sleep.

After throwing the bombs, Bhagat Singh and his friend deliberately courted arrest by refusing to run away from the scene. During his trial, Bhagat Singh refused to employ any defence counsel.

In jail, he went on hunger strike to protest the inhuman treatment of fellow-political prisoners by jail authorities. Along with fellow comrades, Sukh Dev and Raj Guru, he was awarded the death sentence for his terroristic activities by a special tribunal on October 7, 1930.

Despite great popular pressure and numerous appeals by political leaders of India, Bhagat Singh and his associates were hanged in the early hours of March 23, 1931. Their bodies were cremated on the bank of the Sutlej in Ferozepur. Bhagat Singh was just 23 at that time. Old timers say that in many places, not a single hearth fire burned that day.

The last paragraph of the leaflet that he distributed (and wrote) in the Assembly Hall said: "We are sorry that we who attach such great sanctity to human life, we who dream of a very glorious future when man will be enjoying perfect peace and full liberty, have been forced to shed human blood. But sacrifice of individuals at the altar of the revolution will bring freedom to all, rendering exploitation of man by man impossible. Inquilaab Zindaabad (Long live the revolution)."

There was a time when the very mention of the name of the young revolutionary stirred the passions of most Indians. Today, the name evokes little emotion.

The method of remembering him, too, has become mechanical. The day Bhagat Singh was hanged is observed as Martyr's Day, when the chief minister of Punjab makes a trip for a memorial function in Bhagat Singh's memory. Needless to say, the politicians have used this occasion more for their ends.

And as for the children of the village, the high point for them is seeing the helicopter in which the chief minister travels.

Bhagat Singh continues to be martyred by the very people of the country whose freedom he fought for. And that is the biggest irony of all.

[*BabeS iN dE 'WooD*]

thanku honest g for sharig dis nd thanxx all.......now i think i was rite !!

[H0nest_L0ver]

Originally Posted by *BabeS iN dE 'WooD* thanku honest g for sharig dis nd thanxx all.......now i think i was rite !!

anytime babes!!!!!!!!!!!!

[jƆï_gRå¢È£µL...]

yeah babes Bhagat Singh mare nahi o ta shahedd hoye ne......... n kite na kite o halle vi harek insaan ch vasde ne
n above all he is still alive in our hearts .....................
salute to the gr8 man ...........................
onna layi ta respect dil cho andi hai
n guri u xctly rite he nevr wantd 2 bcm any presdnt or so o ta desh layi infact sade layi qurbani de k gaye aa.........

n ishu who said he wasn successful.............
HE WAS n He IS............
aj apa azad desh ch bethe aa ...................... onna ne apna desh azad karaan nu hi ta qurbani ditti c......... onna walo shuru kite kai kamma ne hi aj ee din dikhae aa apan nu bas afsos is gal da hai k o aap azad Bharat nahi dekh sake..................

but yes he ws successful.............

but onna de kamma nu apne citizns ne nakara kar ditta corrupt ho k n stuff .................................................. ..........

inqalab Zindabad ..............


this is link to bhagat singh's web site is supported by Shahid Bhagat Singh Research Committee, Ludhiana with a view to make available the original Photographs and documents of Shahid Bhagat Singh and his Copatriots alongwith documents and photographs of Indian Independence Struggle.
visit fr sure

http://www.shahidbhagatsingh.org/index.asp?linkid=1

[Dhana_Jatt]

I feel ashamed to see the thread’s heading “WHY DIDN'T BHAGAT SINGH SUCCEED?” Rather if you wanted to discuss it, you should have named it “Did Bhagat singh Succeed?”
By the topic you are yourself stating that Bhagat singh didn’t succeed, which is totally FALSE.
And about success, for sure he got success. He wanted to die for his country and we all know he died for the country.
By popularity you only get fame not success, success is achieved when you have done what you wanted to do.........
he wanted freedom for country
baki tusi aap socho bhagat singh nu jad fansi lagi c ta ohdi umar 23 saal di c...matlab sade umar da c.... eni choti umar ch aapne desh layi hass ke fansi charan wale surme nu plz is tara nal rolo... i request ki is thread da naam change kita jave....je rakhna hai ta “Did Bhagat singh Succeed?” rakhlo...
baki kayi dina to main soch reha c ki ost kara ki nahi... mainu heading vekh ke bohat dukh hoya.... so reh ni hoya....baki bhagat singh di bezti nahi seh sakda so likh reha jo dil ch c.....

[jƆï_gRå¢È£µL...]

yes dhanne thats rite
thats wat i said he wsn unsuccessful at all...........................